Paleontology Scandals and Alleged Theft from Grad Students
While perusing PZ Meyers’ blog I read an interesting entry about a brouhaha brewing up in the paleontological world over alleged theft of naming rights to specimens.
In Summary
A graduate student, Bill Parker, completed his master’s thesis using a New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science specimen
He argued that the specimen was unique enough to warrant its own name and submitted a paper to the Journal of Systematic Paleontology in which he bestowed a new name on the specimen.
The rules of paleontology apparently state that whoever publishes first gets naming rights. I’m not a paleontologist, but apparently naming a new specimen is very important and can make a Paleontologist’s career.
Parker’s article to the Journal of Systematic Paleontology was reviewed by Spencer Lucas.
Here comes the murky and alleged parts:
Lucas then published a paper in an New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science’s in-house publication (which is not peer reviewed) two-weeks prior to the January 2007 publication date of Parker’s article.
Parker is alleging that Lucas used his position in the Museum and as journal reviewer to steal the naming rights away from Parker.
Given the timeline presented, Parker’s allegations have a lot of merit
after the break - the allegations mount
Continue reading "Paleontology Scandals and Alleged Theft from Grad Students" »



