Minority Report

Posted by at 2:53PM

I recently posted on diversity of the graduate student population at Stanford. A recent editorial in Nature Medicine discusses this a little more (my emphasis):

The typical American lab is peopled almost entirely with white scientists. That’s not reflective of society at large. A shake-up of the way minorities are recruited, trained and promoted could give minority representation in science the boost it so badly needs.
In 2000, the US population was 75% white, 12% black and 12% Hispanic. But the proportion of minorities that completed biology PhDs between 1993 and 2002 did not match these numbers: only 2.6% of new PhDs were black and only 3.7% were Hispanic. The proportion of tenure-track biology faculty in 2002 was even more disparate: 89% white, 1% black and 2% Hispanic.
These disturbing statistics tell only part of the story. According to first-person accounts, because minorities are often the only one of their ethnicity in their lab or department—perhaps even in their institution—they often feel isolated from their co-workers. Because they lack colleagues from their own ethnic group, they may feel unable to effect institutional changes to address the unique challenges they face.

Personal perspective after the jump.

I have a lot of self-confidence, perhaps more than is warranted. But graduate school can be tough. I’ve served on numerous committees and chaired the biomedical graduate student organization, BioMASS, so I’ve spent a fair amount of time talking to a lot of graduate students. One thing that is quite striking is the large fraction of students who contemplate dropping out for various reason. When you are a minority and don’t see anyone “like” you around the halls and in the labs, this doubt is amplified.
When I first got to Stanford I felt very isolated when I would go weeks without seeing any other Hispanics or even African-Americans. It was pretty common to wonder if I truly belonged here. As a minority who has been told multiple times–both explicitly and implicitly–that I shouldn’t even bother trying, that I’m not smart enough, etc., the doubt weighed heavily on me. I remember one particular African-American woman on the fourth floor of my building that I would see every now and then. I almost always felt like hugging her every time I saw her. When one of my heroes/mentors/friends (an old high school teacher) passed away my first year, it was particularly hard. Things have gotten much better, but it was definitly rough those first months. My meager writing abilities will never be able to adequately express some of the feelings that I felt.
I know from first hand experience, that the Deans, faculty and staff in the School of Medicine have put a lot of effort into increasing the graduate diversity in the SoM. I applaud their efforts and am truly greatful. But the barriers are still large. I believe that it’s more than just a money issue. The problem has to be something that people on every level of the university must recognize and find to be important. I am not convinced that is the case here at Stanford and would guess its the same elsewhere.
I don’t want to diminish the work of the people who have already done a lot to address the problem, but until there is a completely broad interest in addressing the problem, I don’t think we’ll get to the right place. And frankly, there is a lot of implicit discrimination. I can’t tell you how many people simply believe that, say, Hispanics don’t go to graduate school because they don’t value that as an endeavor, that they would rather “play baseball” or something similar (yes, that’s almost a verbatim comment from a fellow graduate student). When you talk to enough minorities, the “values” argument doesn’t seem to carry much weight.
We have a long way to go but I’d like to believe we’ll get there in my lifetime.


4 Responses to “Minority Report”

  1. Build Your Confidence says:

    When entering into a new world, you really need to have self-confidence to be able to adjust with the new environment easily. If you are a bit shy, you need to build your confidence to get along with the people smoothly. You may not want to really mingle with them, but you can’t avoid it all the time.
    To build your confidence may not be that easy. But you have to work your way to it. It is also a preparation when you have to step a little higher in your life or in achieving your goals.

  2. Building Self Confidence says:

    It is natural to get shy when you are new to one place or environment. Even if you feel like you had enough self confidence, it doesn’t mean that you’ll have it all the time. Sometimes it will take time to show your confidence to a new world you entered because you have to adjust first and know their culture or ways.
    Building self confidence would be easier for you since you already have it. You just need to regain it while adjusting at the new environment.

  3. Mark says:

    It is very interesting that even at highly educated levels, there is a feeling of isolation. In my experiences training and occupational culture / language classes can go a long way to reducing barriers in the workplace. I work mostly with immigrant populations so it is interesting to see that the feeling isolation can apply more broadly.

  4. sedona method says:

    Venturing on to something new could be challenging. You have to cope with the new things in your life.
    You need to feel and think positive all the time to help you deal with change. The sedona method is one effective way to get yourself positive by achieving emotional wellness. It will make you feel great and keep you motivated so as to help you in coping with the new things in your life.


Comments are moderated and will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive. Please do not be alarmed if your comment does not show up immediately. We will get it posted soon.